Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Trent Richardson Interviews Fellow Brown Brandon Weeden

Big 12 Legacy

Football:

Vasherized was there to record the developments from the open practice, Geoff Ketchum is opposing the new development on the grounds that it gives up too much of what worked the last 2 years. I'm feeling better from hearing both opinions.

Sure the 3-step passing game of Colt's prime was good to Texas, but it was also dependent on super-accurate Colt throwing darts underneath to the Quan and Ship both of whom he had been throwing to for 2 entire seasons before the breakthrough. Mack can't ask every quarterback to step in and immediately have the necessary timing and accuracy on short throws to execute that offense. Colt was barely able to do it without Quan.

Gilbert's strength is the deep pass and that has to be set up by a running game. Incidentally, one of our best WR talents is a go deep guy (Williams), the OL is comprised of big maulers and they actually have a FB-type on campus in Barrett Matthews. Everything points towards man-blocking and under center sets.

Just as sticking with the Vince Young offense was foolish with Colt it would be a comparable miss-allocation of resources to just plug plug Gilbert into the Colt offense.

You may have heard the morning guys on 1300 creating top 5 lists for "best Big 12/NFL players". I think a list like this basically serves to create a sense of who the real dominant football players are, the guys who exceed at every level. Their lists were pretty negligible but I'll just mention that they featured Dante Hall and Shane Lechler and decided to ignore linemen for reasons best described as stupid.

I've comprised my own list in typical Nickel Rover arrogance that my opinion will be better.

5). Vince Young

Arguably (meaning that I will argue this with you) the greatest college player of all time. Vince won just about every offensive and overall award in 2005 that was granted and lost the Heisman in a now notorious oversight. He was the Rose Bowl MVP twice, etc. Thus far in the NFL he has been Rookie of the year and is a two time pro-bowler. He may jump up this list towards the end of his NFL career.

4). Casey Hampton

In college he led the team in tackles in 99 and 00 from the NT spot and was an All-American. He claimed to have never been pancaked and inspired a very special story from ClosetoJumping in HS ball. In the NFL he's been a 5 time Pro-Bowler, defensive anchor in the 3-4 for 2 SuperBowl champion teams led by defense, and a rich man in general. You can mention Kevin Williams, Pat Williams or Tommie Harris but neither of the Williams had the same kind of college career and I think Hampton has had similar success to Harris over a longer period of time.

3). Adrian Peterson

Almost hit 2,000 rushing yards as a freshman and was the heisman runner-up (Matt Leinart) and an All-American. His next 2 seasons were both shortened by injury and still almost allowed him to jump Billy Sims on the OU all-time rushing list. In the NFL he was ROY and has been named to 3 pro-bowls. If not for the injuries he might have surpassed Ricky's college feats and could do so in the NFL.

2). Evil Roy Williams

Best player on a champion (2000), Nagurski and Thorpe Winner (2001) most TFL in a season by a OU secondary member (12). Roy Williams terrorized the college level unlike anything I ever want to see again from a Sooner defender. Imagine if Texas had 2009 Earl Thomas for multiple seasons, that's what it was like. In the NFL he made it to 5 Pro-Bowls and had some devastating seasons before the NFL passed the Roy Williams rule, he began to lose his place in a pass-heavy league, and became a born-again Christian and lost some of the viciousness that made him so dangerous. Nevertheless, a sustained run of terror through both leagues.

1). Ricky Williams

2nd all-time leading NCAA rusher behind Ron Dayne, Heisman winner, and 2-time Doak Walker award winner. Ricky absolutely dominated the college game. It took a 9-man front to stop him and even then the outcome was in question. The end of his record immediately at the hands of Ron Dayne was universally acknowledged as a great travesty because Ricky was clearly the superior player. If not for Vince he would go down as the most dominant UT offensive player of all time.

His pro-career has been marked by retirement, marijuana and social anxiety disorder and lost in that chaos has been 6 1,000 yard seasons and a Pro-Bowl appearance (harder to make Pro-Bowl at RB). Ricky has had some incredible longevity in the NFL along with some great seasons that, when added to his college career, make him the Big 12's most successful player

Yeah, all Texas and OU, but I defy someone to name a Big 12 player not involved in the RRS who is a strong enough candidate to knock one of these guys out. In the future this could change as newer stars enter the NFL but that's how I see it for now.

Basketball:

Trips Right had another brilliant write-up of the OU game and as someone who was there I can attest that this is a different team in many ways when Hamilton is in rhythm on the floor. His passing was contagious and the floor spacing with Jordan was much better more conducive to the high-screen game. The offense runs best through Jordan.

Scipio Tex made his defense of Rick Barnes the man and Texas coaching legend and that's really all there needs to be said about it. Particularly the point that this squad happened to respond less well to his style while others have responded perfectly. I'll always root for Rick Barnes teams even when I'm thinking about putting sharp things through my temple in the next road game during an offensive possession.

Tied in with the praise for how Barnes has handled care of the UT basketball program is this detail. I want to win a championship as badly as most but if you're putting good kids into the world and into the NBA that's a pretty lofty accomplishment. I'm reminded again that Colt made me prouder with his post game statements after the Championship then he could have with another gutsy victory.

That said if Hamilton doesn't play at least 25 minutes against Baylor I might become feral.

Comment 25 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

Enjoyed the round up, Nickel. Good stuff.

That said, move up Casey Hampton. I’m pretty biased towards both the Steelers and interior D-Linemen (my favorite position players, for sure), but even by your own criteria, Big Snack should probably top that list.

by PB @ BON on Mar 4, 2010 1:58 AM CST reply actions  

Another reason to change our offense: People figured our shit out. We played 3 good defenses last year and they beat, raped and threw our bloody corpse in a dumpster behind a Stop N’ Go.

We have more talent than anyone we play. If we line up and give them a good mixture of play action passing, power running, screens, etc we will have success.

by Newy25 on Mar 4, 2010 6:06 AM CST reply actions  

Spring is the time to experiment. If Davis doesn’t give the downhill running game/play action passing game a real chance at this point, we’ll never know whether or not it suits this set of players. I don’t think we’ve got the running backs to make this work. The problem is that we don’t have the wide receivers to execute the short passing game either. True freshman wide receivers seldom make a real dent in our offense. The defense better be real stout next year.

by lawdog13 on Mar 4, 2010 6:23 AM CST reply actions  

“Gilbert’s strength is the deep pass and that has to be set up by a running game. Incidentally, one of our best WR talents is a go deep guy (Williams), the OL is comprised of big maulers and they actually have a FB-type on campus in Barrett Matthews. Everything points towards man-blocking and under center sets.”

Exactly—not to mention more ball control while a talented young defense settles in and replaces Kindle, Houston, Muck and ET early in the year.

by hopefulhorn on Mar 4, 2010 7:50 AM CST reply actions  

lawdog13: Vondrell Mcgee has long been considered an I-formation running back struggling in our scheme. Really the only guy that I think is more of a zone-runner is Tre Newton and he can still serve as a 3rd down back if he’s replaced.
Shead, Whaley, McGee, CoJo, and maybe even Fozzy would all likely benefit from this transition.
You’re right though, we don’t really have the receiving corp for the short passing game, maybe if Goodwin was around more…

by Nickel Rover on Mar 4, 2010 8:34 AM CST reply actions  

Are there feral humans?

by Eskimohorn on Mar 4, 2010 8:51 AM CST reply actions  

Timmons will be the short passing game guy.

by Richard C. Hottelet on Mar 4, 2010 9:57 AM CST reply actions  

Newy – I wouldn’t say Bama shut us down. We scored 21 points with a true Freshman back up.

The reason OU and NU stopped us is because they really didn’t have to respect the run. That is part of figuring us out, but I think part of it is having a terrible OL not run block for a running scheme that is horrible. We ran the ball 2 years ago with JC in more or less the same offense. If we have a better OL (or a JC who doesn’t need the best OL) and make a few better calls/scheming on the running game, suddenly NU and OU can’t blitz like crazy and jump every short route.

He Who Shakes Spears at God was also an unstoppable force of nature that greatly impacted our ability to run….or do anything. I actually would have liked to see Vince vs Suh. That would be fun.

by 06_UT on Mar 4, 2010 10:13 AM CST reply actions  

I would caution you against going feral. It takes a really robust immune system to survive that.

by dasmithjones on Mar 4, 2010 10:21 AM CST reply actions  

Fozzy with a lead blocker will be pretty good. He always looks good when he doesn’t have to break a tackle in the backfield or at the line of scrimmage. Plus he’s probably the best receiver out of the backfield (might be a toss up with Tre).

by llogg on Mar 4, 2010 10:31 AM CST reply actions  

Everyone looks better when they don’t have to hurdle the boddies of their OL and break tackles 5 yards deep.

by 06_UT on Mar 4, 2010 10:36 AM CST reply actions  

“The reason OU and NU stopped us is because they really didn’t have to respect the run. That is part of figuring us out, but I think part of it is having a terrible OL not run block for a running scheme that is horrible. We ran the ball 2 years ago with JC in more or less the same offense. If we have a better OL (or a JC who doesn’t need the best OL) and make a few better calls/scheming on the running game, suddenly NU and OU can’t blitz like crazy and jump every short route.”

The reason the NU and OU defenses wipped our ass is because they could consistently pressure the shit out of Cot only rushing 4. More importantly they wipped out ass because nobody on O-Line could handle Suh or Granger by themselves or at times, at all. Both of these teams refrained from blitzing, for the most part, unless we were in an empty set in which they brought 6 and squatted on routes.

Alabama’s defense was shit. If it was not for dropped passes, and or the Colt injury we would have bludgeoned them with our offense.

by Fico on Mar 4, 2010 11:49 AM CST reply actions  

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Feral_child

Most of the those kind of look like how I imagined Pip from Great Expectations looks like.

by milksteak on Mar 4, 2010 12:33 PM CST reply actions  

Rover, most of our backs – particularly the bigger ones – probably will be better in an I scheme. We just don’t have anyone back there who is elite in any scheme. Unless and until we recruit someone who is – hello Malcom Brown – we will over time necessarily put more emphasis on our strength, namely Gilbert (assuming we can find someone to catch his lasers). Lots of time between now and next Fall, but I don’t see many consistent weapons on this offense right now.

by lawdog13 on Mar 4, 2010 12:38 PM CST reply actions  

Next year will be Gilbert’s 1st year as a starter. A solid running game tremendously reduces the pressure on the young QB. The current UT backs may not be elite but we haven’t seen them run with good blocking yet. If the blocking improves, the running will improve. If the horns can run well enough to mostly keep the D out of nickel and dime packages, it will be much easier for Gilbert to pass.

by kafka on Mar 4, 2010 2:42 PM CST reply actions  

Besides practising so much with Gilbert under center, Mack’s emphasis on h backs this spring makes me think he is serious about improving the run game. Cody Johnson, Whale, Barrett Mathews, and others have been talked about by Mack as possible h backs this spring and next season. These are all guys who are big enough to block an LB or maybe even a DE yet also can be valuable as pass catchers. In other words, they are multiple.

Having an O that can both pass and run efficiently makes the horns much more dangerous in the hurry up O.

by kafka on Mar 4, 2010 2:53 PM CST reply actions  

Best Feral Kid ever:

the feral kid road warrior

by Sailor Ripley on Mar 4, 2010 5:33 PM CST reply actions  

“Newy – I wouldn’t say Bama shut us down. We scored 21 points with a true Freshman back up. "

They also forced 5 turnovers that led to at least 21 points.

by Newy25 on Mar 4, 2010 5:45 PM CST reply actions  

Pro Bowls simply mean you either wanted a trip to Hawaii or your doctor wouldn’t write you a note to miss the game. No way Vince was among the top quarterbacks in the AFC this season and yet he was in the game with Schaub.

Three players that belong on that list ahead on Vince are Kevin Williams of Minnesota, Kyle Vanden Bosch of Tennessee, and Ahman Green. It could be argued based upon more yards and a higher ypr that Green could be #1 on your list.

As far as the rule change for Evil Roy big fucking deal. If you are Wilt an they widen the lane, prevent you from jumping from the free throw line on free throws, and ban dunking you are a game changing once in a lifetime player.

If the NFL decides to tighten up on spearing and things such as standing over the much bigger man you just knock out (i.e. Jack Tatum) you are a true bad mf’er.

If you are too fat, too slow, and too undisciplined to take proper pursuit angles you are dragging people down from behind I guess you are a great safety. Go figure.

by voiceintheback on Mar 4, 2010 8:28 PM CST reply actions  

Russell > Wilt.

by Burnt Orange Wookiee on Mar 4, 2010 11:52 PM CST reply actions  

Voiceintheback: go watch some Roy Williams highlight tape sometime. Horse collaring people from behind was but one of his evil tendencies. He ran a 4.53 at the combine so he was never slow. At any rate, my point was that he had a method that was so prominent and popularized that the NFL had to ban it (because it’s so dangerous). He was the best player on one of the Big 12’s best defenses ever and won a title.

You can say that ProBowls don’t mean anything but if you are there you are pretty good. It wasn’t my biggest determinant, obviously since Ricky only went to 1, but it’s silly to say they are meaningless.

Kevin Williams just missed the cut because he simply didn’t do that much in college. He blew up Senior year and in that season failed to make a huge impact in their games against either Texas or Oklahoma. Maybe he was a better pro than Roy but the college career counts just as much.
Ahman Green was maybe an oversight but I’m not putting him over the greatest college football player who, in 3 seasons in the NFL, has been ROY and held an impressive W-L record.
VandenBosch in the top 5 is a joke. He hasn’t been a nationally top player in the NFL and didn’t set the world on fire in the Big 12 either. Not like these 5 did.

Overall, if Wilt is your example of greatness then I’m not impressed with your case. I’m sure we can throw in your Husker boy Suh in 5 years or so after he ends MacNabb’s career with a body slam or something.

by Nickel Rover on Mar 5, 2010 1:47 AM CST reply actions  

Wilt isn’t a standard of greatness? Nothing else needs to be said.

by voiceintheback on Mar 5, 2010 5:58 AM CST reply actions  

One of the all-time worst underachievers in the history of American sport. If he had anything close to an understanding of team sports his teams would have won every championship and he wouldn’t have been traded twice in his prime.
His greatest asset was a desire to puff up personal stats through the application of his enormous size which dwarfed everyone else in the league.
Roy Williams never dominated like Wilt (few do in any sport and none in football) but the rule changes for him were for the safety of players. He was doing something that was effective enough to have repercussions throughout the league and he was doing it to people his own size.
I don’t know if you watched the Sooners in 2000, 2001 or the Cowboys in the first several years with Roy but he had a big impact.

by Nickel Rover on Mar 5, 2010 11:41 AM CST reply actions  

Roy Williams was good not great in the NFL. His use of the horse collar was overplayed. He didn’t use it all the time and he wasn’t the only one. Hell, in high school, that was the only way I was able to make a tackle. The reason he isn’t good anymore is he was never a good ball hawk safety. He was always a glorified linebacker and undisciplined. Look at his most famous play in college, it was something that the coaches specifically told him not to do but for some reason we have fucking Brett Robin in on the most important drive of your season. It was a dumb play that got rewarded with bad blocking. His downfall with the ‘boys came in that infamous Monday Night Game against the ’Skins when they couldn’t do anything offensively the whole game and they throw two bombs to Santana Moss who goes ride by Roy and they ’Skins steal one. He just good never cover.

Vince Young should not be on that list. You are putting way too much weight on his college career and not enough on his NFL career. Pro Bowls don’t mean shit anymore. Its about numbers and wins. While he has the wins, he doesn’t have the numbers. You need the numbers too as well, otherwise Trent Dilfer would be considered a great quarterback.

If you are not going to put Williams Kevin Williams because he didn’t have a great college career then you can’t put Vince Young in their because he hasn’t had a great NFL career.

by PrimeTime on Mar 5, 2010 2:23 PM CST reply actions  

Let’s say that you can get 50 points for your college career and 50 points for your NFL career. If Vince only scores 30-40 for his NFL success he’s still doing pretty well cause I’m giving him all 50 possible points for his college career.
Kevin Williams scores 30s for college and 40s for NFL. It just doesn’t add up.
Also, Vince Young has had some solid numbers besides just wins. And Pro Bowls mean something.
Roy Williams led the Cowboys in tackles for several seasons. When the league became more pass-heavy and a roving safety who plays around the LOS became less valuable he declined. To say he wasn’t a good ball-hawk safety isn’t really fair because he forced turnovers in college and early in the NFL he just wasn’t an interception machine like little Earl.

With this list I wanted guys who were national figures in College AND in the NFL. Who are the guys who we watch destroy on sundays but can’t help but reminisce on their careers in the Big 12?

by Nickel Rover on Mar 5, 2010 2:36 PM CST reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

An SB Nation blog mostly about the Texas Longhorns.

Managers

Archer_290_small Scipio Tex

Bc_logo_257x257_small Sailor Ripley

Editors

Nobis_small nobis60

Link2_small BrickHorn

Propeller_helmet_small Huck L Berry

Picture_016_small srr50

Boyd_small Vasherized

Justified-olyphant_small jc25

Billlittle0_small Fake Ken Tremendous

Authors

Williams_ranger_dugout_small WWMcClyde

Jonathan_tjarks_small tjarks

Small ColoradoAg

Long_illustrated_beard_small LonghornScott

Small Nickel Rover

Small John Kocurek

Thumbnail_small Drew Kelson

Barker Emeritus

Tn_homeimage7_small Parlin

220px-henry_james_by_john_singer_sargent_cleaned_small HenryJames

Small Doperbo