Connect with your Facebook Account

• Contact

Football Articles

4

Swimming in the Talent Pool

Posted by BRAGGonUT on June 25th, 2008 under Football, Recruiting

Just before Signing Day, we talked here about the Recruiting Rankings analysis that SMQ performed and he concluded how accurately Rivals was predicting winning percentages.

“Rivals was very, very good at picking the top teams – of the top 25 winningest teams of the last six years, all were either pegged in or very near their respective positions by the recruiting rankings or achieved them by winning against overwhelmingly lower-ranked opposition; of the top 25 teams according to the recruiting rankings, 18 are in the top 30 in winning percentage.”

I also noted how narrow the field really is for teams that can win a BCS national championship.

The BCS Champions since 2002 (Ohio State, LSU (2x), USC, Texas, and Florida) were all in the top 12 of the recruiting averages. Of the “other” 7, OU and Miami both played for in the BCS NC game; Auburn got snubbed in 04 when they were undefeated; Michigan was a game away in 05; and Georgia made an argument to be in the BCS NC game this season.

To project for the upcoming season, I decided to built a model on top of these same Rivals rankings after adding the incoming freshman class (and removing the recruiting classes that are no longer on campus) to see who could actually be in the running to win it all. I ran two models on the Rivals rankings from 2004-2008 (5 classes): simple average (same as SMQ’s original analysis) and a weighted average model. The weighted average model uses the following percentages for 04-08 classes respectively: 15%, 35%, 25%, 15%, and 10%. Essentially, 4 year seniors account for 35% while incoming freshman account for 10%. Yes, completely arbitrary, yet educated guesses.

Ironically enough, the same 12 teams make the cut to win it all using both calculations. The order is different, however.

Simple Average
1. USC 2.4
2. Florida 5.6
3. Georgia 7.0
4. Florida State 7.4
5. Oklahoma 7.8
T6. Michigan 9.2
T6. LSU 9.2
8. Miami 9.6
9. Texas 10.8
10. Alabama 11.0
11. Ohio State 11.4
12. Auburn 14.2

Weighted Average
1. USC 1.6
2. Florida State 5.5
3. Oklahoma 6.1
4. Florida 6.4
5. Georgia 6.6
6. Michigan 8.3
7. Miami 9.3
8. Ohio State 10.6
T9. Texas 10.7
T9. Auburn 10.7
11. Alabama 11.1
12. LSU 11.2

Bodog’s NCAA futures seem to overwhelmingly agree:
USC 3/1
Florida, Georgia, Oklahoma, Ohio State are all 6/1
LSU 12/1
Auburn 20/1
Texas, Michigan 30/1
Miami 35/1
Alabama 40/1
Florida State 50/1

The only teams better than 50/1 according to Bodog are Missouri at 14/1, Clemson at 22/1, West Virginia at 25/1, UCLA at 35/1, and Virginia Tech at 40/1.

Clemson comes in at #20 and #15 in my simple and weighted average formulas, respectively. UCLA #24 and #22. Virginia Tech #25 and #21. Missouri #36 and #40. West Virginia #44 and #39.

These five all seem like “ride the wave” picks as opposed to legitimate title contenders.

Your thoughts?

Article Tags:

, , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

More from this Barker


Share This

  • StumbleUpon

4 Responses

  1. dedfischer said:

    June 25th, 2008 at 8:06 am

    Interesting. So, it looks like USC is the safest bet to play for the NC. Florida State is in there, but let’s throw them out for now. That leaves OU, Florida and Georgia as all being pretty even. That sounds extremely realistic to me.

  2. TxTower said:

    June 25th, 2008 at 1:36 pm

    Throw in a SOS factor to weigh against the talent on the field and you might have something there.

  3. ChrisApplewhite said:

    June 25th, 2008 at 5:38 pm

    Unless Matt Stafford gets a whole lot better UGA probably won’t be a realistic pick. He is only one guy not playing up to his ranking but he is the most important guy on the field.

  4. Buzzard Lips said:

    July 6th, 2008 at 8:57 am

    I think the premise is a bit skewed without taking SOS and the over-rating of certain Rival’s team rankings into consideration. Otherwise, interesting work. I’m also curious about the differential between the betting lines and Florida States rankings… I think the bettors have better info.

Leave a Reply

Follow Us

Related Articles

Hot Forum Topics

Activity

  • Nate Heupel commented on the blog post LeGarrette Blount Fights His Way Back On To The Field 1 hour, 17 minutes ago

    Let’s not kid ourselves, Ripley. Aside from teams based out of Watts, no one in the Pac 10 really plays defense.

    SHARETHIS.addEntry({ title: ””, url: ”” });

  • Sailor Ripley commented on the blog post LeGarrette Blount Fights His Way Back On To The Field 1 hour, 47 minutes ago

    I think Oregon could’ve used Blount a time or two against Stanford, don’t you?
    I dunno. Does he play defense?

    SHARETHIS.addEntry({ title: ””, url: ”” });

  • Sailor Ripley commented on the blog post LeGarrette Blount Fights His Way Back On To The Field 1 hour, 47 minutes ago

    I think Oregon could’ve used Blount a time or two against Stanford, don’t you?

    I dunno. Does he play defense?

    SHARETHIS.addEntry({ title: ””, url: ”” });

  • Nate Heupel commented on the blog post Who’s Not Playing 2 hours, 24 minutes ago

    It would’ve been better if the injuries had been more evenly spread out, HJ. On defense, we’ve got some very talented depth we’re simply not taking advantage of. LB Ronnell Lewis is a name you’re going to remember come 2011. Dezmon Briscoe already can’t forget it. At DE, we’ve got RJ

    SHARETHIS.addEntry({ title: ””, url: ”” });

  • Nate Heupel commented on the blog post The Texas Longhorns: Running Game Home Edition 3 hours, 35 minutes ago

    @ballrific: On the contrary, I think Boom is much more subtle here at Mack’s request. He’s probably put a Deathwatch clock on his wall to remind him that there is hope. 680 days, 13 hours, 17 minutes, and 41 seconds until Greg Davis’ career dies.

  • Charles commented on the blog post Tracking Baylor & Potpourri 3 hours, 55 minutes ago

    Let’s do this Big XII style:

    A la carte Briles
    Bo Linguine
    Mike Sherbet
    Ndamukong Soup

  • HenryJames commented on the blog post Who’s Not Playing 4 hours, 25 minutes ago

    Do you think it would be better or worse if they were more evenly spread out on both sides of the ball?

    SHARETHIS.addEntry({ title: ””, url: ”” });

  • The General commented on the blog post Tracking Baylor & Potpourri 4 hours, 30 minutes ago

    Ded, It took me about ten reads before I figured that one. Then I belly laughed for ten minutes. Strong work, young pirate.

  • The General commented on the blog post Christian Scott eligible for bowl game? 4 hours, 33 minutes ago

    Curtis Brown would be sitting with the band. Aaron Williams would be in line at the concession stand.

  • bigdukesix commented on the blog post Mack Brown’s First 150 Games 4 hours, 53 minutes ago

    I can realize his flaws but also admit that I wouldn’t take anyone other than Mack as our head coach.

    That’s at the opposite end of the spectrum from irrational criticism, and is an equally flawed position. Somewhere in between the two is the Golden Mean.

  • Rick Vigorous commented on the blog post Tracking Baylor & Potpourri 4 hours, 59 minutes ago

    Michigan all time wins…877

    Texas all time wins…840

    And the gap is quickly closing.

  • Nate Heupel wrote a new blog post: LeGarrette Blount Fights His Way Back On To The Field 5 hours, 40 minutes ago

    Duck Sport News

    Honestly, I have no problem with this. First, I was overwhelmingly pleased with Blount dropping a Falcon Punch on some random Boise State jackass. Second, after the honorable Brandon Spikes, who knows dirty play when he sees it, attempted to eye-gouge some random Georgia jackass and only got a one-game suspension against

    SHARETHIS.addEntry({ title: ””, url: ”” });

  • Nate Heupel wrote a new blog post: Who’s Not Playing 5 hours, 51 minutes ago

    Take a look at our injury list, and tell me we’re not paying for 2000 when not one of our starters missed a single game. The following players have missed at least one game.

    QB – Sam Bradford

    TE – Jermaine Gresham

    DE – Auston English

    OL/TE – Brody Eldridge

    RB -DeMarco Murray

    OL – Brian Simmons

    OL – Ben Habern

    WR –

    SHARETHIS.addEntry({ title: ””, url: ”” });

  • HenryJames commented on the blog post Quotable Mack 6 hours, 15 minutes ago

    I wasn’t being cynical so I highlighted the part that made me laugh.

  • parlin commented on the blog post Quotable Mack 6 hours, 22 minutes ago

    Intentional irony like this seems rare in Mack’s repertoire.

    Do any other instances come to mind?

  • The General commented on the blog post Quotable Mack 6 hours, 42 minutes ago

    Who do you call to steal him some more snaps on offense? Oh, yeah . . .

  • HenryJames wrote a new blog post: Quotable Mack 7 hours, 48 minutes ago

    Talking about Malcolm Williams at today’s press conference:

    “Malcolm’s about 220 pounds, and it’s amazing to me that he’s on kick coverage, he’s on punt coverage, he’s on the kickoff return team and playing 35-40 plays a game and making a difference. I walked into Oscar Giles’ office and tried to get him off the kickoff

  • Colin Coe commented on the blog post Basketball Thoughts 7 hours, 55 minutes ago

    I’m ready for bb !!

    SHARETHIS.addEntry({ title: ””, url: ”” });

  • Nordberg commented on the blog post Christian Scott eligible for bowl game? 8 hours, 16 minutes ago

    “The biggest downside I see is that our guys would all be running around in circles before the play without Blake out there to line them up, right?”

    Curtis Brown would be sitting with the band. Aaron Williams would be in line at the concession stand.

  • Sailor Ripley commented on the blog post Tracking Baylor & Potpourri 8 hours, 29 minutes ago

    Holy shit, that’s funny.

  • Triston27 commented on the blog post I’ve got nothing 8 hours, 34 minutes ago

    I’m fearing that with our seasojnj gone and their win on Saturday, we may need to brace ourselves for a whole lotta red this weekend.
    Prime recipe for KU fans unloading tickets to now-excited Huskers.

    I was thinking of this earlier today. It could be pretty ugly. Also, I completely agree about the lack of

    SHARETHIS.addEntry({ title: ””, url: ”” });

  • dedfischer commented on the blog post Tracking Baylor & Potpourri 8 hours, 36 minutes ago

    Union dudes aren’t big on Mexicans.

  • Bob in Houston commented on the blog post Tracking Baylor & Potpourri 8 hours, 57 minutes ago

    srr, I said “bad fit” before, and I’m more convinced than ever.

    If RR were to have a 10-win season, he’d still be disliked. You know it doesn’t bother me to see Michigan struggle, but he’s gotta go.

  • Sailor Ripley commented on the blog post Tracking Baylor & Potpourri 8 hours, 58 minutes ago

    srr50 has written some great stuff about Michigan and Rich Rod:

    https://www.barkingcarnival.com/tag/rich-rodriguez/

  • Jason commented on the blog post Mack Brown’s First 150 Games 9 hours, 12 minutes ago

    Three things come to mind when Mack Brown comes up as a coach.

    First, he’s turned Texas into a recruiting juggernaut. I would argue the success he has had through his last 100 games has just as much to do with the talent he’s brought to the 40 acres as his coaching.

  • Hiphopopotamus commented on the blog post I’ve got nothing 9 hours, 16 minutes ago

    I think they have too – just haven’t seen that emotion in a while (can’t even remember the last Fist Pump). It’s hard to believe, but there were certain goals out there that are no longer attainable. When that happens, it’s hard to have the same drive, especially when it feels like everything is going

    SHARETHIS.addEntry({ title: ””, url: ”” });

  • Scipio Tex commented on the blog post Christian Scott eligible for bowl game? 9 hours, 17 minutes ago

    I was thinking about special teams too. Fairly streamlined assignments there.

    I don’t know if the coaches would feel comfortable giving him too many snaps on D in a national title game given his absence all year.

  • Hiphopopotamus commented on the blog post And so it begins 9 hours, 30 minutes ago

    Very much agreed, Sailor. Considering heading down to Austin for that one. Let me know.

    SHARETHIS.addEntry({ title: ””, url: ”” });

  • Levander Williams commented on the blog post Tracking Baylor & Potpourri 9 hours, 34 minutes ago

    @texasholdem:

    I lost track of the fact that there were only 40 seconds left in the game when Colt ‘would’ have gone back in the game to get the remaining four yards. Clearly this would not have been the right time to send Colt back in the game, and it would have looked petty –

  • spider commented on the blog post Mack Brown’s First 150 Games 10 hours, 15 minutes ago

    Aaaaaaaaand I misplaced three games.

    Again.

    I’m, like, the Colorado Buffaloes of math or something.