clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

SB Nation BlogPoll Top 25: Week 4

New, 27 comments

Server problems all day yesterday and intermittent today (I just lost an entire post-mortem post). We're back online and regularly scheduled programming is back underway. We're in the process of migrating over to a new platform, and post-migration, this should happen less often and your load times should be substantially improved.

**

Let's talk polls. We now have some actual football under our belts and separation is starting to occur. Ha ha. No, it's not. It's all an illusion. We still don't know anything. As the ballots will quickly reveal.

Here's how all of the blogs collectively see it:

College Football Rankings 2011

Results for Week 4

# School Points/blog SD Delta
1 Oklahoma Sooners (54) 24.68 2.33 Arrow_up 2
2 LSU Tigers (39) 24.26 2.19 --
3 Alabama Crimson Tide (11) 23.17 1.79 Arrow_down -2
4 Boise St. Broncos 21.46 0.41 --
5 Wisconsin Badgers 20.22 0.62 Arrow_up 2
6 Stanford Cardinal 20.13 1.49 Arrow_down -1
7 Oklahoma St. Cowboys 17.14 3.27 Arrow_up 1
8 Texas A&M Aggies 15.75 4.10 Arrow_up 1
9 Nebraska Cornhuskers 15.66 4.15 Arrow_up 2
10 South Carolina Gamecocks 13.99 3.89 --
11 Oregon Ducks 13.61 4.68 Arrow_up 2
12 Florida St. Seminoles 13.50 5.08 Arrow_down -6
13 Virginia Tech Hokies 12.89 3.69 Arrow_up 1
14 Arkansas Razorbacks 12.88 3.96 Arrow_down -2
15 Florida Gators 12.05 3.44 Arrow_up 1
16 West Virginia Mountaineers 9.70 3.21 Arrow_up 2
17 South Florida Bulls 8.77 4.13 Arrow_up 2
18 Baylor Bears 7.88 4.03 Arrow_up 2
19 Clemson Tigers 6.50 4.28 Arrow_up 20
20 Texas Longhorns 6.36 3.87 Arrow_up 3
21 Michigan Wolverines 4.54 4.19 Arrow_up 4
22 USC Trojans 4.53 4.81 Arrow_up 2
23 Georgia Tech Yellow Jackets 3.42 4.14 Arrow_up 10
24 Illinois Fighting Illini 3.40 3.93 Arrow_up 11
25 TCU Horned Frogs 2.87 2.84 Arrow_up 1
Others Receiving Votes: Iowa St. Cyclones | Houston Cougars | Fla. International Golden Panthers | North Carolina Tar Heels | Michigan St. Spartans | Vanderbilt Commodores | Miami Hurricanes | California Golden Bears | Maryland Terrapins | Missouri Tigers | Utah Utes | Arizona St. Sun Devils | Ohio Bobcats | San Diego St. Aztecs | Mississippi St. Bulldogs | Penn St. Nittany Lions | Ohio St. Buckeyes | Iowa Hawkeyes | Georgia Bulldogs | Pittsburgh Panthers | Notre Dame Fighting Irish | Auburn Tigers | Temple Owls | Texas Tech Red Raiders
Updated: Sep 20, 2011 6:32 AM PDT

SB Nation BlogPoll College Football Rankings 2011

Capable commentary provided by Andy Hutchins. You'll note that Barking Carnival won a Homer Award mention for ranking Texas #18 instead of the BlogBorg's average #20. WE ARE OUT OF CONTROL! Actually, the real reason is that the deviations get pretty small once you get past the Arkansas and Nebraska homers.

Here's how I see it:

SB Nation BlogPoll Top 25 College Football Rankings

Barking Carnival Ballot - Week 4

Rank Team Delta
1 LSU Tigers Arrow_up 1
2 Alabama Crimson Tide Arrow_down -1
3 Oklahoma Sooners --
4 Boise St. Broncos Arrow_up 1
5 Wisconsin Badgers Arrow_up 1
6 Oklahoma St. Cowboys Arrow_up 3
7 Stanford Cardinal Arrow_up 4
8 Arkansas Razorbacks --
9 Florida St. Seminoles Arrow_down -5
10 Texas A&M Aggies Arrow_up 2
11 Oregon Ducks Arrow_up 3
12 Nebraska Cornhuskers Arrow_down -2
13 South Carolina Gamecocks --
14 South Florida Bulls Arrow_up 2
15 Virginia Tech Hokies Arrow_down -8
16 West Virginia Mountaineers Arrow_up 1
17 Florida Gators Arrow_up 1
18 Texas Longhorns Arrow_up 2
19 USC Trojans --
20 Illinois Fighting Illini --
21 Michigan Wolverines --
22 Baylor Bears Arrow_up 3
23 Georgia Tech Yellow Jackets --
24 TCU Horned Frogs --
25 Houston Cougars Arrow_down -2
Dropouts: Arizona St. Sun Devils, Tennessee Volunteers, Michigan St. Spartans, Central Florida Knights, Ohio St. Buckeyes

SB Nation BlogPoll College Football Top 25 Rankings "

My primary bones of contention:

- LSU is my new #1 because they've beaten two solid to good football teams handily on the road and at a neutral site. They're also physical as hell. Now they play West Virginia and tackle a brutal SEC West schedule. Hats off to the Hat. LSU schedules like men.

- Oklahoma's win over FSU was good stuff, but you can't help but wonder if it revealed vulnerability (Landry's early performance wilt, OL play) as much as revealed OU's strength (defensive hitting, high quality of WRs).

- The BlogPoll, AP, and Coaches polls are all beguiled by Clemson for beating Auburn at home (Clemson rose 20 spots from last week's ranking in BlogPoll). I continue to have them unranked. First, as I've detailed, I don't think Auburn is all that good. They play zero defense. The Clemson Tigers are 3-0 with three home wins as follows: Troy (surged late), beat the dreaded Wofford Terriers by 8, and mediocre Auburn. I'll hold off on my crush for Clemson.

- If you counter my argument with "What about Baylor? Or "What about Texas?" I can only say...good point. Clemson is just very Clemsony. They reek of an embarrassing road loss just waiting to happen. Isn't that what Clemson IS?

- Everyone likes Nebraska and South Carolina more than I do. Nebraska's defense is surprisingly porous and South Carolina seems to struggle mightily with every opponent. I forgive all teams that struggle with Navy to some extent, but South Carolina REALLY struggled. They could have easily lost that game at home. They will ride a surprisingly forgiving SEC schedule to an inflated ranking for a few weeks longer.

- I ranked Houston out of sheer stubbornness though I dropped them two spots. Another weak performance, even in victory, will put them out of the top 25. Edging out Louisiana Tech? Really, Houston.

- I also severely punished Virginia Tech for its continued underachievement against a feeble schedule. The ACC feels like a giant confidence game. Virginia Tech has a real shot at building up a strong record on tomato cans, but a quality bowl opponent will provide an epic pantsing unless they can create some offensive focus. They have the tools. The offense just seems to operate with a natural governor on its speed. Governor Frank Beamer?

- Ranked Georgia Tech for the sheer wonder of a football team rushing for 600+ yards in a college football game. Poor Kansas.

Thoughts? Comments?