Texas Longhorns Defensive Player Draft - Fantasy & Reality (1)
As I look at the Big XII, much has changed over the years. Back in my day, there wasn't as much parity and uncertainty. Every year we knew that we would roll through Baylor, that Okie-State would start strong but allow us to come back, that Tech would put up great numbers but ultimately fall short on the scoreboard, and that OU would determine whether we were BCS-bound or not. Intentionally omitted: 2 losses to K-State because I still haven't figured that shit out.
Now you have TCU as a legitimate in-state recruiting threat and a West Virginia roster full of speedsters out of Florida. Oklahoma State is a consistent challenger who's found a way to source talent and win games (and the conference). Baylor is serving something in the dining hall that has them kicking ass in every sport. OU, in spite of some unfortunate events, will reload with players who we forgot were from Texas or just finished their stint in JUCO. Every other team in the conference will continue to spread it out on offense and hope to catch you slipping on a random Saturday when you're more focused on the Chi'lantro Korean BBQ (since Roppolo's is no longer an option) that you'll be eating after hanging out later that night.
The conference has become unpredictable, especially on the offensive side of the ball, and I see no sign of that changing. While Bryan Harsin continues rebuilding the Texas Longhorns into a unit that can control the game and outscore people, the Longhorns defense doesn't have the luxury to wait it out. The Big 12 schedule is coming and they may have to win some games (and even score some points).
I've been charged with the task of drafting two Texas Longhorns defenses.
The first draft will be a fantasy draft predicated on first ranking the most important positions to flourish in this Big XII, 1-11, and after each one, selecting a former Longhorn who played during my tenure to fill that spot.
The second draft will be selecting from the guys we have to go with this season. Being # 11 on this list doesn't mean it's an unimportant position or the player isn't talented, it's just fun to explore while we wait for the real games start. Manny Diaz will play a lot more than 11 guys every game but let's get my best / most important 11 in order.
Here's the first of 11 posts.
Fantasy Draft 1st Pick (Position & Player): Safety | Michael Huff
In the new Big XII the position I want to take care of first is an elite do-it-all Safety. That's why I'd draft Michael Huff. He's one guy I know for certain could come into this conference and be THE difference-maker for the defense. S stands for safety but with Huff, it might as well stand for Swiss Army Knife - equally strong in coverage and run support and a guy who could get everyone lined up correctly, from the core of the defense to the secondary. His game against OU in 2004 was one of my favorite performances by him and a prime example of his diversity. He somehow limited Mark Clayton to 19 yards on 3 catches, while keeping Adrian Peterson (240 yards on 32 carries) out of the end zone. There were several times in that game where Peterson broke a long run that would have gone for scores vs. most other teams. Huff, with 15 tackles and a pick, gave us a chance we would not have otherwise had in the loss. The consensus is we're loaded in the secondary this year but I don't think we quite have Huff's mix of talents (namely, his speed and instincts) roaming around back there this year. The good news is our secondary is quite good and they'll have what I consider a DB's best friend helping them - pressure from the edge.
Reality Draft 1st Pick (Position & Player): Defensive End | Alex Okafor
As we've heard before, you can only go to war with the army you have, not the one you wish you had. Since I cannot have uber-Safety Michael Huff, who I believe plays the most valuable position needed to thrive in this Big XII, I have to draft the most important position / player based on our roster. In a totally different way, I believe Alex Okafor will provide an influence in the run and pass defense that I believe will surpass that of anyone else we have on the 40 Acres right. Working with Jackson Jeffcoat as a tandem cannot be overlooked and I believe they will make our DBs who are already very good, look great. But I give Okafor the slight edge based on the way he finished last season and the how he's prepared for the upcoming season.
If the league is as unpredictable as I anticipate, the Horns must maximize their opportunities on the most predictable downs in football. A defense must be able to deliver when they know exactly what's coming because those opportunities are rare. With 3rd and long, a scenario Manny Diaz's defense focuses on creating, being one of the most predictable downs in football, you absolutely need a guy you know can get to the quarterback and get the defense off the field. Any 3rd down that is converted is painful but converted 3rd and longs influence momentum exponentially and put more mileage on the legs of the defense. With his combination of length, power, and explosiveness, I strongly believe Okafor will be the executioner on those predictable downs this year. While I believe Manny Diaz can draw up blitzes to create pressure, there's nothing more valuable than being able to just rush your 4 guys up front, knowing you have a talented DE (and we have two) that could get to the QB when you need to get off the field. As far as my draft goes, Okafor is the best bet for lowest risk and highest reward. He's definitely the first guy I want to make sure is on the bus each week.
So those are my first pick(s).
There are so many philosophies to the game that affect the value of players and positions. So I ask you, what position do you think is the most important? What player would be your 1st pick this year? Which guys from the prominent eras of Texas Longhorn Football history do you think would flourish in the Big XII as it stands today?
Second Draft pick(s) coming soon...
32 comments
|
Add comment
|
2 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
I'd think if safety is the most important position...
Wouldn’t you make a case for Kenny Vaccaro over Okafor? Vaccaro and OU’s Tony Jefferson are easily the two best safeties in the league, and right now even I’d give a slight nod to Vaccaro.
by NateHeupel on Aug 11, 2025 5:37 PM CDT reply actions
Much respect Nate
Jefferson is certainly one of the players nobody would have blamed you for preferring. I appreciate the objectivity.
Follow me on Twitter @GoHornsGo90
by GoHornsGo90 on Aug 11, 2025 5:48 PM CDT up reply actions
He may be one of the top safeties in the league...
But I don’t think he’s the best player on this defense. Please don’t get me wrong. He’s damn good. But he spends less time in the middle of the field roaming and cleaning up than Huff did which I believe is important for this league. He blitzes much more and is much more involved with robbing routes underneath. I’d like to see them expand his role more because he’s playing in a way that’s a little less traditional for safety. While its perfect for what we do as a defense, it doesn’t show the full acope of what i think he could be on this level and the next. But there’s no doubt a case can be made for him.
by Drew Kelson on Aug 11, 2025 6:31 PM CDT up reply actions
quotes from Vaccaro
seem to indicate that Diaz would like to use him more like Huff this year. Encouraging him to attack the ball and be more instinctual.
I think though, that his value in locking down receivers in man coverage or blitzing off the edge is pretty high and we’re going to keep seeing it.
by Nickel Rover on Aug 11, 2025 6:49 PM CDT up reply actions
Nice read man
I especially liked the Roppolo’s comment.
Here’s a question that you’ll probably end up answering in further posts, but whatever. Are saying you’d take Mike Huff over Derrick Johnson because of the positional impact itself, the impact Mike had vs. DJ, or a bit of both? I know the importance of stud LB’s is often less stressed in the Big 12, but Johnson (along with Ndamukong Suh) is the best defensive player I’ve personally seen since I’ve been watching football.
Admittedly, that’s only about decade (good God, it’s really been that long now), but all in all not a terrible sample size since it’s been 12-13 hours a Saturday for that tenure as well.
He was also fantastic in coverage and in space, if memory serves correctly, and about as perfectly suited to play OLB in the B12 as one could conceive. As simply put as I can make it, “how much deference are you giving to the positional impact vs. the player himself, or do you merely view Huff as a superior player overall?”
I would have assumed you just drafted a safety, period, initially. But then you went with another “conference value” position in Okafor instead of a guy like Vaccaro.
This has gotten rambly. Apologies. Answer if you can, but I don’t blame you if it doesn’t make any freaking sense.
Follow me on Twitter @GoHornsGo90
by GoHornsGo90 on Aug 11, 2025 5:48 PM CDT reply actions
The idea was...
Most important position in building a D, 1- 11. Choose that position and fill it from past stars.
Now, looking at this year’s team, who would you take first weighing everything (talent, impact, positional importance, etc.).
I’ll let Drew speak for himself but I think he thinks THAT much of Huff’s game and that much of Okafor’s game. I bet Kenny V is next off the board but he hasn’t told me yet.
by Sailor Ripley on Aug 11, 2025 5:56 PM CDT up reply actions
I love DJs game...
He was a star from the moment he set foot on campus at Texas. But I feel Huff would have more influence and impact in this league. Now, depending on what defense you run and how players we used, a case can be made for several guys. But, from an overall skillset standpoint, I couldn’t pass up Huff.
by Drew Kelson on Aug 11, 2025 6:37 PM CDT up reply actions
hmm
First pick is Orakpo. Need to have pressure in this league. Plus let him walk off the bus without a shirt on just to scare the women and children.
This year I take Byndom. Nothing is more valuable than a lock down corner. Just gives you so many options
by codaxx on Aug 11, 2025 6:01 PM CDT via mobile reply actions
but
I believe Orakpo had the highest season sack total and career. Orakpo also understood the benefit of a good night sleep. Not the case with Kindle.
by codaxx on Aug 11, 2025 6:40 PM CDT via mobile up reply actions
in Kindle's defense
he had several games where he impacted the QB and the passing game without actually finishing the play with a sack. Ask Earl Thomas, the common beneficiary.
Kindle also had a huge impact on opposing running games. Orakpo was probably a more skilled pass-rusher but Kindle may have been the better all-around player.
by Nickel Rover on Aug 11, 2025 6:54 PM CDT up reply actions
its a close call
But Orakpo is safer pick. Main reason is not about football
by codaxx on Aug 11, 2025 7:27 PM CDT via mobile up reply actions
Risk vs. Reward
Fundamentals of drafting.
by Drew Kelson on Aug 11, 2025 8:06 PM CDT up reply actions
Taylor Taliban is probably in Gitmo right now.
He can think whatever he wants, but Osama bin Lubbock is probably getting the waterboarding he deserves.
(Side note: That year’s Tech SOTU still makes me laugh)
by NateHeupel on Aug 13, 2025 11:45 PM CDT up reply actions
Scouts and GMs
Argue over this kinda stuff for months before draft day. Loving the discussion.
by Drew Kelson on Aug 11, 2025 6:33 PM CDT reply actions
I think I'd take
a dominant pass-rushing DT first before anything else.
I’m not sure if I’d be willing to take anyone over Huff though. Lamarr Houston may have been our best for that purpose and I’m not sure he had a greater impact on games than #7.
Okafor vs. Vaccaro is a tough pick. I went the other way in my PB annual article but Oak is pretty important. If/when he adds dominant pass-rushing to his skills as a run-defender he becomes the better player unless Vaccaro becomes as instinctual as little Earl or Huff and starts contributing more TO’s.
Hopefully both occur and the debate remains difficult.
Looking forward to the rest.
by Nickel Rover on Aug 11, 2025 6:34 PM CDT reply actions
Was Thomas, Duke of Earl, under consideration ahead of Huff?
He’d be damn close to the top of my list. Couldn’t go wrong with either guy.
Huff had the slight advantage of the secret weapon flying scissor leg grapple takedown. He found out pretty quickly that didn’t work in the NFL.
by Vasherized on Aug 11, 2025 9:21 PM CDT reply actions
Huff over Gideon?
Please. Sounds like someone needs to review the game tape. Gritty, heady, and a rapier wit.
Always my first choice.
by ShameAndFailure on Aug 11, 2025 11:49 PM CDT via mobile reply actions
I love DE's that rush the passer
And with that said my 1st pick would be Orakpo and I think Phil Loadholt would agree with me. He and Tony Brackens my two favorite Horns.
"If crime was justified by need it would be the occupation of the masses."- Chief Gillespie
by 2Cor12:9 on Aug 12, 2025 12:47 AM CDT via mobile reply actions
Good stuff, Drew
Looking forward to the series.
Intentionally omitted: 2 losses to K-State because I still haven’t figured that shit out.
None of us have, brother. Not even Mack Brown.
Every other team in the conference will continue to spread it out on offense and hope to catch you slipping on a random Saturday when you’re more focused on the Chi’lantro Korean BBQ (since Roppolo’s is no longer an option) that you’ll be eating after hanging out later that night.
Glad to know we share the same taste in drunk food. Kebabalicious ain’t a bad second choice.
Derrick Johnson is probably the Fantasy #1 if this was 10 years ago. Wonder if Jeffcoat is the pick at #1 in the Reality if he you knew he was fully healthy. I just wonder how you’re going to stop at 11. So many talented players to pick from, in both drafts.
http://aseaofblue.com | https://www.barkingcarnival.com | @JC_Hoops
by jc25 on Aug 12, 2025 6:54 PM CDT reply actions
You lost me at.....
“Now you have TCU as a legitimate in-state recruiting threat…”
Did Jonothan Gray flip while I was watching Yu Darvish walk another batter?
by Philly Frog on Aug 13, 2025 9:20 AM CDT reply actions
My draft pick depends on how the draft is run.
Are we just ranking players/positions or a real draft vs an opponent (picking teams).
If the latter, then you have to pass on secondary as your first pick, and I’d think you’d even pass on DE (whoever loses out on one of Orakpo and Kindle can just take the other with their next pick). That leaves LB and DT.
Its very hard to pass on Derrick Johnson, especially since there’s just one of him, but if you’re building a team to beat the modern spread offense, a do-it-all DT is more important than a LB corps that will be in nickel most of the time anyway.
So if we’re picking teams, I’d take Lamarr Houston with the first overrall, even acknowledging he’s not the best player overall from that group. For the rest if I don’t get Huff I can take Thomas, and if I don’t get Orakpo I can take Kindle. DT pool is much shallower.
by CMDR on Aug 13, 2025 10:11 AM CDT reply actions
That made me laugh out loud.
At first in hysterics, then ruefully. Then I got angry.
by Sailor Ripley on Aug 13, 2025 2:42 PM CDT up reply actions
Something to say? Choose one of these options to log in.

- » Create a new SB Nation account
- » Already registered with SB Nation? Log in!


















