Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
New Blog: Land-Grant Holy Land: for Ohio State fans!

My 2012 NBA Awards And All-NBA Teams

Kevin Durant...not my MVP

The regular season is coming to a close and it's time to assess the top players in a lockout shortened season.

First, my unsolicited MVP ballot.

MVP - Lebron James

Hating on James is an enjoyable national past time (The Decision ever lingers) and I'd love to defend a homer vote for the best ambassador for basketball in the world in Longhorn Kevin Durant, but Lebron's consistent dominance has been the story of the season. The objective evidence is:

  • The Heat are 13-1 without Dwyane Wade in the line-up, overall second best record in the East
  • James leads the league in PER, averaging a stat stuffing 27.1 ppg, 7.9 rpg, 6.2 apg. When you average 27-8-6 every night, you're doing what you want on the court. Those are Bird/Magic/Jordan/Robertson numbers
  • Lebron is the best defender in the league. He can guard four positions, his on-ball pressure is searing, and he can throw around NBA power forwards inside
  • He's shooting 53%. Of all of the stats you can cite, for a high level scorer playing the 3 position to shoot >50% from the field is remarkable.

Star-divide

As for the subjective, other 3 time MVP winners are Larry Bird and Magic Johnson and though that equivalence of achievement may make you retch a bit given Lebron's absence of titles, that's not really what a regular season MVP award is about.

The NBA played a season. He played the best in it. That is all.

Runner Up - Kevin Durant

Kevin is likely to win the league scoring title (28 ppg) again on nearly 50% shooting and his rebounding (8.0 rpg) and assist numbers (3.5 apg) are at career highs. Durant continues to evolve his game (he now has the strength and savvy to stake his spot at 15 feet) and is the most feared late game shooter in the league. He's also one of the game's most underrated finishers in transition and his defensive length affects passing lanes and shot selection even when he's saving his juice for offense.

Did I mention he's 23? TWENTY THREE. The 4th year pro is still growing his game and he has the young OKC Thunder as legitimate title contenders.

3rd Place - Chris Paul

Equipped with a roster of dogs and solid role players and one very athletic, one dimensional high-flying forward, Paul has made the LA Clippers relevant and playoff bound. CP3 has the highest basketball IQ in the league, scores exactly as many points are needed to win (and 12 of his 20 points are usually in the 4th quarter) and is an opportunistic defender who leads the league in steals. His PER rating is head and shoulders above any other point guard and a sneaky second to Lebron James (actually ranking above Durant). His 19.8 ppg and 9.1 apg stat line - though impressive - doesn't reflect his full impact on a franchise abundant with loser's inertia. Paul is a mean, competitive little shit who sets the tone for a team with a personnel mix that would love to underachieve without his prodding.

Not coincidentally, the above three will form the core of our Olympic team in London.

Coach of the Year - Gregg Poppovich

Do I even have to defend this? The Spurs have the best record in the league playing with somewhere around the league's 8th best starting talent, they lost their 2nd best player for most of the season, they've adopted an up tempo style of basketball to exploit Tony Parker while still respecting veteran legs, dispersed minutes freely, but always wisely, with a beautifully constructed bench, and have played chess with the compressed season schedule while the rest of the league plays checkers.

I won't even name a Runner-Up as it implies that there was some competition for the award.

Rookie MVP - Kyrie Irving

He has exceeded my expectations and is becoming a top notch NBA point guard. He can get into the lane at will and is developing into a solid shooter. He also had a weak draft class - easy pick.

1st Team All-NBA

C - Dwight Howard. Even when he's coach-killing and blundering PR, he's the league's best center. 20.6 ppg and 14.5 rpg, dominant defensive presence. Hold your nose and move on.

F - Kevin Durant.

F - Lebron James.

G - Kobe Bryant. Bryant has been lauded for elevating the Lakers without Odom, but the truth is that they have 3 of the best 15-20 players in the league, Andrew Bynum is an under-utilized scoring force, and Kobe's ego forces him to take 5 shots per game more than needed. He's shooting 43% from the field. 30% from 3. He has been Iversonian.

You know what?....I'm going with combo guard Russell Westbrook. Yes, I'm being that guy - the one who changes player positions to suit his own agenda. He may shoot too much, but a higher percentage of them go in and his defensive energy can be stifling. With Wade missing too many games for me to place him on a team, it's revealing how depleted the NBA shooting guard position currently is.

G - Chris Paul. Apologies to Tony Parker (who has a real argument if you understand contextual hoops).

2nd Team All-NBA

C - Andrew Bynum. 18-12 and he's an underutilized asset despite shaky maturity level. He's absolute money on the low block. So why isn't he getting it more?

F - Kevin Love. I just put a dude averaging 26-13 on my 2nd team. It's not a lack of love for Love, just an understanding that Durant and Lebron are at the top of their games and his 44% field goal percentage prevents a usurpation of the natural order.

F - Blake Griffin. 20-11 with nearly 55% shooting and still hasn't developed a reliable face-up game. Sky is the limit. He gets the nod because Nowitzki struggled so badly in the first half of the season. I understand recency bias and last year's amazing playoffs argue against this choice because it feels so wrong, but the relevant body of work is only this season and it says that the Mavericks are the #7 team in the West.

G - Kobe Bryant. Primarily because I want to antagonize Laker fans and Bynum's dominance in Kobe's absence tells you a little something.

G - Tony Parker. On a per-minute basis, one of the most efficient players in the league. When needed, fully capable of dropping 28 points and 13 assists. When not needed, he'll score 8 points in 21 minutes with 7 assists and watch the Spurs cruise. Don't get so statistically focused that you can't see the greater truth - Parker is dominating.

3rd Team NBA

C - Al Jefferson. I give Al the nod over Tyson Chandler in a close race. 19-10 is pretty impressive and he's doing it the hard way in Utah. Ranks 3rd in PER among centers. Saw a recent game against Dallas where he went for 28 points and 26 rebounds. Moses type stuff.

F - Dirk Nowitzki. He's starting to be himself again, but Dirk really sucked early.

F - Paul Pierce. See Dirk. Same story. No Carmelo? Damn right.

G - James Harden. Cooly efficient, good handle, great distributor, clutch scorer. Gets the nod over Paul George and Joe Johnson.

G - Rajon Rondo. Best pure distributor in the NBA and a defensive force despite offensively retarded game. Steve Nash has been extraordinary for Phoenix given his age, but his defense is in the bottom quintile of the league. Kyrie has an argument, but Boston has been hot since the All-Star break.

Thoughts:

Obviously, injuries influenced my selections (Rose, Wade absent) and I have a revealed bias for efficient players who will sublimate their games for a greater good. I tried my best to limit my perspectives to this season only.

Also, filling out these teams may have made me re-examine the "2s and 3s grow on trees" wisdom. Lots of good forwards out there. 2s, maybe not so much. James Harden may be more valuable than Ibaka after all.

I'd love to hear your thoughts.

Tweet Comment 36 comments  |  Add comment  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

More from Barking Carnival

The Thunder's Long-Term Dilemma

Apr 2012 by tjarks - 23 comments

2012 USA Olympic Basketball: The Next Dream Team

Apr 2012 by Scipio Tex - 84 comments

Sweet 16 Thoughts And Observations

Mar 2012 by tjarks - 32 comments

Caption Contest 3-6-12

Mar 2012 by Sailor Ripley - 17 comments

Caption Contest 3-2-12

Mar 2012 by Sailor Ripley - 11 comments

Comments

Display:

Lebron

Is @JonathanTjarks favorite player.

More defense of the Once and Future King.

by Sailor Ripley on Apr 25, 2025 5:36 PM CDT reply actions  

Harden easily a top 3 SG.

Great point on the dearth of SGs this year. I’m an even greater efficiency nut than you maybe so I love some of these choices, especially Kobe to 2nd team. I do respect Kobe’s magnificent PR transformation from petulant brat/rapist all the way to supposedly being the unquestionable best SG. It’s mind numbing to me. I’ll fully admit that I don’t like him. He could be so much better at winning for how much people thinks he cares about it.

I think my first team would be same (though unsettled on the Westbrook pick). Admittedly, I have to think twice about inserting Love for Durant. He was consistently great this year. Shot the 3 real well, dominated the glass and improved his scoring. Dunno if he’ll ever be great defensively…but still, best true PF in the league and it’s not even close for 2nd place I think due to Nowitzki’s spattered greatness. Help me out here if I’m wrong and there’s another worthy pure PF… but Durant…love him. He gets my nod too. Gonna keep thinking on who the second guard is, but the westbrook pick is a nice choice.

by Burnt Orange Wookiee on Apr 25, 2025 6:00 PM CDT reply actions  

Agreed

I’m not sure I could keep Love off the list until I consider removing James or Durant and then it becomes pretty palatable.

by Nickel Rover on Apr 25, 2025 9:39 PM CDT up reply actions  

And Kobe

yeah. If you shoot it 29 times per game, turn it over nearly 5 times, and only shoot 43% you are not helping your team.
He has coasted on the unseen contributions of 7 footers his entire career.

by Nickel Rover on Apr 25, 2025 9:41 PM CDT up reply actions  

It is Kobe’s least efficient scoring year of his career, based on true shooting percentage. Also his second highest usage rate, which seems strange given where he is in his career.

I am on Twitter @jeffchaley
Burnt Orange Nation
Hoop-Math

by Reggieball on Apr 26, 2025 12:27 AM CDT up reply actions  

Phil Jackson once said

he never wanted to coach Kobe when he was no longer Kobe. He got out at the right time.
I wouldn’t put him anywhere near the All-NBA lists.

by Nickel Rover on Apr 26, 2025 7:56 AM CDT up reply actions  

mvp

Can you be MVP when you consistantly pass up on the big shot? When you are the second option on your team inside of a minute? Everything else says he is MVP, but just hard to get over that

by codaxx on Apr 25, 2025 9:00 PM CDT via mobile reply actions  

by that argument

Russell, Chamberlain, and Jordan when he passed to Kerr would all forego the MVP award.

by Nickel Rover on Apr 25, 2025 9:31 PM CDT up reply actions  

red herring

Jordan passed the ball once.

by codaxx on Apr 26, 2025 7:48 AM CDT up reply actions  

actually

it is insulting to Jordan’s career to even say something like that. Guy was one of the best closers the game has seen.

by codaxx on Apr 26, 2025 7:49 AM CDT up reply actions  

sure

and by that inane argument that the best players “take the last shot”, then Jordan would have failed in a crucial moment to live up to his duty.

To ignore the 45 minutes of a game before the final 3 in their impact on the outcome is one of the most egregious errors in logic made by sportswriters and fans of the NBA.

by Nickel Rover on Apr 26, 2025 7:58 AM CDT up reply actions  

i am not

it is simply not about the last few minutes. It is not like guys are having bad yrs. I completely get your pt. I just cant get over the shrinking. My issue isnt that me misses those shots, because frankly I think “clutch” is an aberration. Just that he passes on shots. Is he more valuable to Miami than Durant to OKC? I am not sure about that. Chris Paul is certainly more valuable to the Clippers. It is the MVP award. Not the best player award.

by codaxx on Apr 26, 2025 10:45 AM CDT up reply actions  

is it

Most valuable to their team or most valuable player? Ty Lawson was essential to the Nuggets, does that enter him into consideration?
I think Durant, while he’s been phenomenal this year, is perhaps less responsible for their greatness than is commonly assumed. I mean…they have the best shooting guard in the league, the best shot-blocker, and Westbrook along with a really solid bench. I don’t think James vs. Durant is a close debate.

As far as James passing on shots, I have no idea what he was doing in the finals but I think he earnestly is interested in making the highest percentage plays in crucial moments.
Kobe, statistically, is not a good player in the 4th quarter. But because of media perception, whenever he makes shots in the 4th he gets credit while dodging most blame when he doesn’t. In the public relations game it’s better to take a bad shot late in the game trying to be heroic than passing the ball.

It’s counterintuitive that the best player wouldn’t make the most famous plays but it’s how smart teams win. After all, if you’re in the NBA you should be able to make an open jumper or layup from a teammate. All these guys were “the guy” at some point in their careers. If you passed me the ball to shoot an uncontested 3 in an NBA game even I would hit one and be the hero now and then.

by Nickel Rover on Apr 26, 2025 11:06 AM CDT up reply actions  

Pretty interesting graph from SI’s recent LeBron feature:

An only child raised by a single mother, James yearned for family, and he called his teammates brothers. He still does. In 2009 he wrote a 256-page book, Shooting Stars, about his teammates at St. Vincent-St. Mary. Being a good teammate — a good brother — means finding the one with the best shot. “If two guys are on you, a teammate is open,” James says. “It’s four against three, easy math.” When he was a junior, his team lost the state championship after he dished to an open man in the final seconds, but his arithmetic has never changed. In Cleveland, coaches tried to explain that four is not always superior to three, because a bad shot from him is better than a good shot from almost anyone else. He couldn’t agree. “He has to make the right play every time,” says Nuggets assistant Melvin Hunt, who used to be with the Cavs. James recoils when he sees a player rise up for a long jumper over three defenders. He beams when his 7-year-old son, LeBron Jr., dishes to a forgotten kid.

Read more: http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/2012/magazine/04/24/lebron.james/index.html#ixzz1tAXDNaE3

by tjarks on Apr 26, 2025 12:33 PM CDT up reply actions  

"I think he earnestly is interested in making the highest percentage plays in crucial moments."

As is Chris Paul. And I think it is good basketball.

KG was always criticised for passing up big shots back in the Minnesota days. I always thought it was dumb.

I am on Twitter @jeffchaley
Burnt Orange Nation
Hoop-Math

by Reggieball on Apr 26, 2025 2:48 PM CDT up reply actions  

I have no problem

if he dishes to the open man. Jordan made Kerr famous that way. AS the MVP he should have the ball in his hands and make something happen. Use his ability to get to the the rim and finish or dish. I am not saying take a shot with 2 guys on you and I will never tell anyone to be like Kobe. You can take my comments as such, but was never said. My issue is he shrinks from the moment at times. Plays are run through Wade and not LeBron. it drives me crazy. I will also admit I can not stand LeBron, so I am probably jaded.

by codaxx on Apr 26, 2025 3:01 PM CDT up reply actions  

if he allows Wade

to run more offense late in games that hardly seems like a major indictment though. Wade is, after all, a HOF’er himself. We’ll see if they still do that in the playoffs this year though.
Ideally they would run offense through whichever of the 2 the opposing team had the weakest defense for.

by Nickel Rover on Apr 26, 2025 3:36 PM CDT up reply actions  

I haven't gone over all the stats lately, but looks like a fairly good list to me.

You’ve written glowingly of Durant and realized the lack of depth among SGs, so you can’t be all bad.

Totally agree with the thoughts on Tony Parker and James Harden as well, but think you might get big but cold shoulders from Chicago fans for choosing Pop.

Good effort, Scipio.

by Saul! on Apr 25, 2025 9:06 PM CDT reply actions  

Chicago fans certainly have an argument

And I can’t say I know much about their situation this year other than the coach did a terrific job while his franchise player was out most of the year.

However, in addition to what Scipio mentioned above, the greatest achievements from Popovich this year were an amazing ability to manage the minutes of his aging stars, without sacrificing many wins, and an almost seamless transition of a bunch of new players. In a strike-shortenend season, with very little preseason workouts, and almost no time for in-season practice, what he has gotten out of Leonard, Green, Diaw and recently Mills has been pretty amazing. Not to mention the growth of the second year players in Neal and Splitter. Even Anderson has been contributing lately.

by Horncasting on Apr 26, 2025 2:29 PM CDT up reply actions  

Chicago?

Haven’t they had Deng, Noah, Boozer, that other center, and Korver healthy almost the whole year? They have a loaded team of superstars, if they didn’t have Rose all the time to subdue the east I hardly feel sorry for them.
Losing Ginobili, though a regular event, was comparably impactful to the spurs as losing Rose was for Chicago.

by Nickel Rover on Apr 26, 2025 3:34 PM CDT up reply actions  

Missing one of the best players in the NBA for most of the season and ending with the best record in the NBA

can’t be overstated, IMO. Could the Lakers have pulled that off without Magic? The Celtics without Bird? Those teams were loaded with superstars. There is no Kareem, Worthy, McHale or Parrish on Chicago.

I believe Popovich is the most deserving, but the Chicago coach definitely has an argument..

by Horncasting on Apr 26, 2025 3:49 PM CDT up reply actions  

To me

that says more about how overrated Rose is than it does about Thibodeau’s brilliance, although I won’t argue he’s not a stellar coach.
Chicago wins with defense though, and their big studs were there all year.
Gibson, Noah, Asik, and Boozer are all better than the 4’s and 5’s on many other teams. Brewer and Korver are pretty underrated as well.

by Nickel Rover on Apr 26, 2025 4:00 PM CDT up reply actions  

I thought I killed two birds with one stone:

Provide another possible point of view and make a verbal jab in jest to Scipio for declaring there was no competition. I even worked in a Chicago nickname in the response for my own amusement.

Now I find you two actually debating the merits. Gosh. Much thanks to Horncasting for taking on the devil’s advocate role and Nickel for the counter punching when it appears we’re all truly on board with Scipio’s pick. Nice exchange.

Anyone want to take up the cause for Doc Rivers? No? Okay, half-heartedly I’ll volunteer.

He put Avery Bradley in the starting five and moved KG to center. He is a genius. The Celtics are old and Danny Ainge wanted to trade Rondo. Kevin McHale isn’t walking through those doors either. Unless, of course, the Rockets are the visiting team some time next season. Did Doc Rivers lose hope and curl up in a ball? No! That’s not what a Doc Rivers stands for. He stands for winning with Celtic pride, and I’m pretty sure Red’s ghost wants Doc to get the award.

by Saul! on Apr 26, 2025 5:12 PM CDT up reply actions  

I see

that my arguments for keeping Harden over Ibaka have gained some traction.

I actually like Chandler for 1st team C, his impact on Dallas last year is about to be made extremely apparent in these upcoming playoffs when they get rolled.
I would put Harden first team SG, I think he was much better than westbrook this year. More efficient because he shot 39% from 3 and also turned it over 2 fewer times per 48 minutes.

One final quibble: Kawhi Leonard as rookie of the year, but only because George Karl is too incompetent to have played Kenneth Faried more minutes.
Leonard’s per 48 avgs: 15.7-10.3 on 49.2%, 2.7 steals and only 1.4 TO.
He’s secretly the reason the Spurs maintained control of the west despite Manu’s injuries and Duncan’s precipitous decline. That and they have a perfect ensemble of supporting players, like you noted.

by Nickel Rover on Apr 25, 2025 9:38 PM CDT reply actions  

Question for those who follow professional men's basketball

I watched precisely zero games this year. How did Tristan Thompson and Jordan Hamilton do this year? Just looking at the stats, TT seemed to have a solid first season and at least Jordan got some exposure. Wanted some views from those who watched them play this year as opposed to judging by looking at a statline.

by Big(g) Ern on Apr 26, 2025 8:51 AM CDT reply actions  

On TT

I get the feeling if there was a redraft he’d fall to the bottom half of the top 10, and they aren’t in love with him, think he’s likely to be a future all star which you’d ideally get at the 4. That’s just my sense, not from seeing him but from reading some stuff from people I think tend to know things.

Jordan got almost no run- but watching his stat line when he did get in he did some things well. I think Denver is a nightmare for him. He’s good enough right now to be the 8th or 9th guys (rotation player) on many a playoff team, but Denver is in the playoffs b/c they are so deep with above average players.

He’d be making a much bigger impact on a team like the Lakers or Celtics or Heat in my opinion- a more top heavy team even if they are better than Denver.

by Wulaw Horn on Apr 26, 2025 10:11 AM CDT reply actions  

Denver

has one of the stupidest coaches in the league when it comes to allocating minutes. Karl values Harrington over Faried by a great deal, which says all that needs to be said.

by Nickel Rover on Apr 26, 2025 11:07 AM CDT up reply actions  

Had a promising year with limited minutes.

I followed him a bit this year. David Thorpe (one of the few NBA analysts I really like) thinks he’s a future star. His offense is raw, but he rebounded well and blocked shots for the minutes he was getting. 8 points, 6 rebounds, 1 block in 24 minutes per game for the season aint bad. Recorded many 3+ block games.

by Burnt Orange Wookiee on Apr 26, 2025 11:34 AM CDT up reply actions  

Can't wait for...

Durant to channel the BS-patented “eff you” mode and destroy MVP LeBron in the Finals. It will be glorious.

by jc25 on Apr 26, 2025 10:18 AM CDT reply actions  

I’d take LaMarcus Aldridge over Blake Griffin right now. Better jump-shooter, post scorer and defensive player, and far more useful in a playoff series.

In other Longhorns in the NBA news — Avery Bradley! Our little boy is all grows’d up! Don’t think Atlanta is the best match-up for him b/c of Joe Johnson’s size but he’s finally starting to put it together.

As for 2 guards, it’s pretty thin right now, but there are 4-5 excellent ones in this draft (Ross, Lamb, Beal, Waiters, Barton) who should inject some talent into that position.

by tjarks on Apr 26, 2025 10:57 AM CDT reply actions  

Boston

do you think they could claw their way to the WCF? I think I could see them taking down Chicago in a brutal-to-watch 7 game bloodbath and sparing Rose the embarassment of getting shutdown by LBJ again.

by Nickel Rover on Apr 26, 2025 11:10 AM CDT up reply actions  

It’s possible. I’m not huge on Chicago, but I think Atlanta will be a tough series for them. Josh Smith has way too much athleticism for the Celtics front-line and Joe Johnson’s presence makes the Rondo/Bradley pairing (which has been huge for them) difficult. That could go 7 games.

by tjarks on Apr 26, 2025 12:32 PM CDT up reply actions  

Too Bad OKC didn't get Chandler

They’d be a stone cold lock to win it all.

by mdhorn on Apr 26, 2025 11:38 AM CDT reply actions  

Love Kevin Love's game

but it’s difficult to grade his stats since Minnesota still sucks. It’s different if they rise and we point to them and say, without Love, they’d be toast. See Dirk for Dallas now but yeah, they miss Chandler and will exit early most likely. He was the difference between Dallas getting rolling the Lakers or Dallas getting swept by the Lakers.

by mdhorn on Apr 26, 2025 11:41 AM CDT reply actions  


User Tools

An SB Nation blog mostly about the Texas Longhorns.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Bc_logo_257x257_small
College Football Playoff Being Finalized
Justified-olyphant_small
Texas Transfer Sterling Gibbs Picks Seton Hall
Bc_logo_257x257_small
Next Arkansas Razorbacks Head Coach Odds
6b1b0e394b8924c736955eaad63a2e85-bpfull_small
Confused RG3 Shown 70 Minutes of Ryan Tannehill Footage During 'Camp Gruden'
Bc_logo_257x257_small
Vince Young Wants To Start
Bc_logo_257x257_small
That's a golf shot.
Boyd_small
Road rash on an overworked hog? Only Clinton can help you now, Bobby
6b1b0e394b8924c736955eaad63a2e85-bpfull_small
Report: Colts Meet With Andrew Luck for Three Hours to Discuss Ryan Tannehill
Justified-olyphant_small
Avery Bradley Doin' Work
Justified-olyphant_small
Cameron Ridley To Commit To Texas Longhorns?

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >


Managers

Archer_290_small Scipio Tex

Bc_logo_257x257_small Sailor Ripley

Editors

Nobis_small nobis60

Link2_small BrickHorn

Propeller_helmet_small Huck L Berry

Picture_016_small srr50

Boyd_small Vasherized

Justified-olyphant_small jc25

Billlittle0_small Fake Ken Tremendous

Authors

Guadfish3_small dedfischer

Williams_ranger_dugout_small WWMcClyde

Small TaylorTRoom

Small mlcotcher

Jonathan_tjarks_small tjarks

Small ColoradoAg

Long_illustrated_beard_small LonghornScott

Salado_small Cirque Du Salado

2478379451_fddcbc40d1_b_small davey o'brien

Small BatesHorn

Small Nickel Rover

Adam_jones_2011_small jonestopten

Thumbnailcahvcqzr_small Kashmere Thoughts

Small John Kocurek

Thumbnail_small Drew Kelson

Barker Emeritus

Small Kevin Berger

Tn_homeimage7_small Parlin

220px-henry_james_by_john_singer_sargent_cleaned_small HenryJames

Small Doperbo